Search Sponsored by:
Saturday, July 23, 2016
Speculator, NY ,

A State Police boat equipped with side-scanning sonar comes into dock after working the lake Monday.

Cristine Meixner - Forest rangers head back out in their airboat.


Drowning victim’s body found

Monday, July 11, 2011 - Updated: 6:52 AM


Express Editor

SPECULATOR - The body of a young man who drowned in Lake Pleasant after his life jacket came off Saturday afternoon was found at 11:59 a.m. Tuesday in 39 feet of water.

Anthony Perez, 19, Bronx, was located by a State Police boat equipped with sonar, according to Sheriff Karl Abrams, and “a State Police diver went down and recovered the body.”

According to Abrams, based on a statement by the only witness, she and Perez took a two-person kayak out on the lake from Camp-of-the-Woods resort, where Perez had been on staff for six weeks. They planned to kayak to the island.

“He wanted to learn to swim,” Abrams said. “She was in the water first, demonstrating how to tread water.

“He got in wearing a lifejacket not properly attached by himself. It came off immediately.

“She tried to give him her lifejacket from the kayak, [which she was not wearing,] but he struggled and went under. I think he panicked.”

They were about half a mile from the shore at Camp-of-the-Woods, Abrams said.


Both were both on staff at Camp-of-the-Woods.

“She was trying to get back into the kayak when a witness came to help and took her to Camp-of-the-Woods and called 9-1-1,” Abrams said. “A second jet-skier kept doing circles in the area but couldn’t find [Perez] and came in.”

A discrepancy between where the young woman said they were when her companion went under and where the two jet-skiers said they were meant a large area of the lake was searched.

Many boaters on the lake started searching immediately as word spread, Abrams says, and HCSO mounted a search soon after being notified at 3:32 p.m. Saturday.


Two forest rangers responded with an airboat, Water Deputy Michael Tracy with his family’s pontoon boat and HCSO with two boats manned by Raquette Lake Water Deputy Corkey Risley and Deputy Corey Hutchins. They dragged the lake Saturday until dark.

The search resumed Sunday morning. “We have been doing grid searches,” Abrams explained. “With personal watercraft patrolling the perimeter to keep boaters away.”

Each morning Paul Beaudoin took his airplane up as soon as the fog lifted and, with Rick Wilt as spotter, flew above the area to see if they could spot the body from the air. Both are from Piseco.


Nineteen official vehicles lined South Shore Road at Cherry Beach Monday afternoon as the State Police boat and divers used “sophisticated hi-tech side-scanning sonar brought in from the Finger Lakes” to search, Abrams said.

The Sheriff’s Office used its own sonar Sunday. “The State Police’s is higher resolution,” Abrams said Monday, hopeful the better unit would do the trick. “They are looking for ‘hot points’ before putting divers back in the water.”


A volunteer team from the St. Johnsville Fire Department’s Dive - Rescue - Scuba Special Operations unit was on shore waiting to be activated. A team member said this is not unusual, especially when such a large area has to be covered.

“We can’t just start diving and then be all tired out,” he explained.

Abrams said at 20 feet visibility is zero, so the sonar team was marking “anomalies” for divers to check out.

The State Police team left at 6 p.m. Monday but returned Tuesday morning.


Volunteers on personal watercraft and on foot - Mike Tracy and K.C. Morrison of Speculator and Craig Small of Piseco - checked the shoreline each morning at first light, Abrams said.

The subject’s family arrived Monday morning, according to Abrams. The young man was a student at a community college in the Troy area.

A Syracuse man drowned in the indoor swimming pool at Camp-of-the-Woods in September of 2002.

Lemar Spruance, 33, was swimming in the pool when he sank to the bottom. A non-swimming friend ran for help, but Spruance could not be saved.

Camp-of-the-Woods opened for the summer June 25. It is sold out this week with 825 guests.


Comments made about this article - 10 Total

Posted By: Deb On: 7/20/2011

Title: Are you kidding me?

I know of no boat, canoe, or kayak rental company that attempts to ensure that renters can swim! If an adult rents a water craft, he or she is responsible to follow safety measures and use good judgment. The rental company is only responsible to see that the equipment is safe and in good working order. Lets not villify a well-run facility for this. With that said, my heart goes out to the family and friends of this young man! What a tragic loss!

Posted By: On: 7/18/2011


In response to the post 2 below this: How does any boat rental (or other similar recreational) facility "ensure safety" when risk exists? (Should a bike rental facility make their renters pass riding, vision, and hearing tests to "ensure safety?" Perhaps, though I think many may instead opt for use of a waiver.)

Posted By: St Just On: 7/16/2011

Title: responsibility

I'd say the camp has a responsibility. We'll see what the lawsuit says.

Posted By: anonymous On: 7/16/2011


"...ensuring that they are renting to adults" certainly isn't ensuring safety when COTW is renting/permitting adults who cannot swim to use their boats, from their facility. Poor decision-making indeed. On the part of COTW. They are responsible and liable for allowing a non-swimming adult out on a kayak in the first place. COTW should not be doing that and that is definitely not "ensuring safety" of their staff and/or guests. Those who cannot swim, adults or not, simply should not be able to rent/use their boats, lifejacket or not. It is not safe. The fact that COTW cannot see this or take any kind of responsibility is appalling.

Posted By: On: 7/14/2011


This is certainly tragic and sad. While any boat rental facility should ensure that life jackets are worn and that they are renting to adults, A facility cannot be responsible for poor decision-making on the part of the renters.

Posted By: Kate On: 7/13/2011


What does it matter that Camp of the Woods is sold out this week? Seems a little insensitive to the subject of the article. A tragic accident and a life lost.

Posted By: anonymous On: 7/13/2011


How does Camp of the Woods allow a "non-swimmer" to go out on the water and use one of their kayaks with a life jacket or not in the first place? Non-swimmers should not bto permitted to use boats, etc, from Camp of the Woods, and it is 100% the responsibility of the establishment. Camp of the Woods' irresponsibility resulted in a tragic accident. They should know which of their employees are non-swimmers and therefore know who is not allowed out on the water in their vessels. A terrible accident that should not have happened.

Posted By: On: 7/13/2011


I agree with Trevor. I have been visiting CotW since my children were very small and it is clear this camp goes above and beyond to assure the safety of their guests AND their staff. My daughter was on staff for part of a season. This is a very sad and tragic event, but it is is clearly not any fault of the camp.

Posted By: John On: 7/12/2011

Title: Where?

Where in the lake was he found?

Posted By: Trevor On: 7/12/2011

Title: typical small town paper

I would like to know what a 33 year old man drowning in a indoor swimming pool in 2002 has to do with this story at all if you are not just trying to undermind the saftey or ability of this establishment to keep its guests safe?

Comment on this article


Copyright © McClary Media, Inc.

Privacy Policies: Hamilton County Express

Contact Us